Saturday, May 3, 2014

Why I'm Against The Death Penalty


My brother was murdered.  Many people know this. Many don’t.  Just over a decade ago my brother and one of his closest friends were brutally murdered. It was not quick. It was horrible and gruesome and disgusting.  The case was strait up out of CSI or Law & Order or something.  I need to make this clear. It was planned, pre-meditated and carried out from beginning to end with all the precision they could muster.

I am thankful every day that the amount of precision they could muster was very little. Authorities caught them relatively quickly and all but one took a plea deal that allowed them to be eligible for parole in 50 years or so. The other, the ringleader, went to trial and went to prison for life.  The jury convicted in less than 30 minutes. It was a horrible time in my life. I wished they’d all die. I hated them; I wanted them to suffer. I was pissed that the state didn’t go after the death penalty but I took solace in the fact that prisoners in Texas die faster in the general population than they do on death row. In that, I found great comfort.

It has taken over a decade (and a lot of therapy) to get to the point of relinquishing my hate.  It has taken me this amount of time to realize their value as humans on this planet and the realization that they are human and have feelings and emotions and are worthy of God’s love.  Now, don’t get it twisted, I don’t want them out of prison. I suppose in many ways I haven’t even forgiven them and don’t particularly feel inclined too. Yet, given the option, I would not put them to death. Not now, not ever. 

You see, death is such a permanent thing. We are such impermanent beings. And in that way, making permanent decisions doesn’t sit well with me. Despite my feelings when I was younger, I realize now that I believe the death penalty to be inhumane. Beyond that, I believe that if I choose retribution over justice or revenge over acceptance then I have lost my way as a Christian.  If I choose an eye for an eye instead of turning the other cheek than I have allowed myself to be ruled by an old law that is absent of love instead of remaining present in Jesus’ assurance. 

The majority of those that read this will know John 3:16 but it is John 3:17 that rings true for me.  It states, “For God did not send his son into the world to condemn the world but to save it.” If I am to be a follower of Christ’s teachings then I cannot, in good conscience, condemn these men to death. So I accept that they suck. I applaud my justice system. I encourage those around me to step away from words like “he deserves to suffer” and “well that’s karma for you asshole” because that man who was put to death may have been awful, but he was human. Since he was human he was worthy of God’s love and because he was worthy of that love he is worthy of acceptance and justice.

Now I know what you’re thinking, “but this IS justice.” I disagree.  Justice is a human ideal with human application.  When we choose to make permanent decisions on impermanent beings we have stepped out justice and into the shoes of God.

There’s all that and then there’s the realization if Jesus was alive today I don’t think He’d like it either.